After designing your ideotype, you need to choose how you’ll select plants to achieve your goals. Let’s look at the main selection methods used in cannabis breeding: bulk selection, pedigree selection, and backcross breeding. We’ll also look at strategies for developing F1 hybrids.

Bulk Selection: Simple but Effective

Bulk selection is perhaps the most straightforward approach - you grow a large population, select the best plants, and combine their seeds for the next generation. While simple, it can be remarkably effective when done properly.

How Bulk Selection Works

1. Start with a diverse population
2. Remove obviously undesirable plants early (negative selection)
3. Select the best remaining plants at maturity
4. Combine their seeds for the next generation
5. Repeat until you achieve desired uniformity

Key advantages:

• Low labor requirements
• Can handle large populations
• Natural selection helps adaptation
• Simple record keeping

Main limitations:

• Less control over inheritance
• Harder to track pedigrees
• May miss valuable recessive traits
• Progress can be slower

Pedigree Selection: Detailed but Demanding

Pedigree selection involves keeping careful records of each plant’s ancestry and performance. It’s more work but gives you much more control over your breeding program.

The Pedigree Process

1. Start with known crosses
2. Track each plant’s family line
3. Select within families
4. Compare between families
5. Maintain detailed records
6. Advance best lines

Key advantages:

• Better control over inheritance
• Can identify superior families
• Easier to avoid inbreeding
• Better for complex traits

Main limitations:

• More labor intensive
• Requires excellent record keeping
• Handles smaller populations
• Needs more growing space

Backcross Breeding: Precision Improvement

Backcrossing is used to add specific traits to an otherwise good variety. It’s particularly useful for introducing disease resistance or other simply inherited traits.

Backcrossing Steps

1. Cross your main variety (recurrent parent) with a donor carrying your desired trait
2. Select offspring showing the desired trait
3. Cross selected offspring back to the recurrent parent
4. Repeat selection and backcrossing 4-6 times
5. Self-pollinate to fix the trait

Key advantages:

• Precise trait introduction
• Maintains most characteristics of recurrent parent
• Good for qualitative traits
• Clear endpoints

Main limitations:

• Time consuming
• Works best for simple traits
• Can lose useful minor genes
• Needs careful selection

F1 Hybrid Development: Capturing Hybrid Vigor

Developing F1 hybrids is more complex but can give exceptional results. The goal is to create parent lines that produce superior offspring when crossed.

Hybrid Development Process

1. Develop distinct breeding lines
2. Test lines for combining ability
3. Identify complementary parents
4. Create test hybrids
5. Evaluate hybrid performance
6. Scale up successful combinations

Key advantages:

• Maximum hybrid vigor
• Uniform offspring
• Protected genetics
• Can combine traits

Main limitations:

• Most complex method
• Requires maintaining parent lines
• Higher production costs
• Needs extensive testing

Choosing Your Method

Your choice of selection method should depend on:

Your Breeding Goals

• Simple trait improvement? Consider bulk selection
• Complex traits? Pedigree might be better
• Adding specific traits? Try backcrossing
• Maximum performance? Look at hybrids

Your Resources

• Limited time/space? Bulk selection is efficient
• Good record keeping? Pedigree becomes viable
• Long-term program? Hybrid development possible
• Technical expertise? Matches method complexity

Your Target Market

• Commodity production? Open-pollinated varieties
• High-value markets? Hybrids might pay off
• Specific needs? Backcrossing could work
• Regional adaptation? Bulk selection helps

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

1. Using too small populations
2. Poor record keeping
3. Inconsistent selection criteria
4. Ignoring environmental effects
5. Rushing the process

Looking Forward

In the next post, we’ll look at understanding and utilizing hybrid vigor in cannabis. Until then, consider:

1. Which selection method best matches your goals?
2. Do you have the resources for your chosen method?
3. How will you maintain genetic diversity?
4. What record keeping system will you use?

Remember: The best selection method is one you can execute consistently and effectively with your available resources.

References

1. Barcaccia, G., Palumbo, F., Scariolo, F., Vannozzi, A., Borin, M., & Bona, S. (2020). Potentials and Challenges of Genomics for Breeding Cannabis Cultivars. Frontiers in Plant Science, 11, 573299. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpls.2020.573299

2. Salentijn, E. M. J., Petit, J., & Trindade, L. M. (2019). The Complex Interactions Between Flowering Behavior and Fiber Quality in Hemp. Frontiers in Plant Science, 10, 614. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpls.2019.00614

3. Salentijn, E. M. J., Zhang, Q., Amaducci, S., Yang, M., & Trindade, L. M. (2015). New developments in fiber hemp (Cannabis sativa L.) breeding. Industrial Crops and Products, 68, 32-41. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.indcrop.2014.08.011

4. Clarke, R. C., & Merlin, M. D. (2016). Cannabis Domestication, Breeding History, Present-day Genetic Diversity, and Future Prospects. Critical Reviews in Plant Sciences, 35(5-6), 293-327. https://doi.org/10.1080/07352689.2016.1267498

5. Small, E. (2018). Dwarf germplasm: the key to giant Cannabis hempseed and cannabinoid crops. Genetic Resources and Crop Evolution, 65, 1071-1107. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10722-017-0597-y

If you found this post interesting, consider hitting the “Buy me fertilizer” button below to chuck a few dollars in the pot. Your support helps this educational resource keep growing!

[This post assumes legal hemp/cannabis breeding in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.]